LETHBRIDGE: Olympic success requires funding
So how did Canada actually do in the London Olympics?
That depends how you spin the numbers.
What we do know is that Canada earned 18 medals, one gold, five silver and 12 bronze.
If you look at the London 2012 rankings from a Canadian vantage point, we ranked 13th. The Canadian Olympic Committee ranks by total medals won.
But if you look up rankings of the International Olympic Committee, you will find a dramatically different story. There we rank No. 36, below Azerbaijan and above Colombia.
The international standard, used by every other country except Canada and the United States, counts gold medal totals.
Each method comes up short. The international ranking system ignores silver and bronze, unless there is a tie for gold medals, in which case other medals are considered.
Canada, on the other hand, places equal value on each medal, whether it’s gold, silver or bronze. That seems a little unfair to the athlete who finishes in first place with a gold.
There are plenty of other ways to slice and dice Olympic rankings, too.
One that makes a lot of sense is a weighted system that awards, say, three points for gold, two for silver and one for bronze. That would put Canada somewhere between 36th and 13th.
In Britain, the Guardian newspaper used statistical analysis to create an alternative medal count.
They ranked countries on a per capita basis. The assumption here is that the larger the population, the greater likelihood of a medal. This means that tiny Grenada would be ranked on top with its one gold medal. Canada would be No. 45.
You could also factor in a country’s wealth, the idea being that countries with more money to spend on training have the advantage.
This means that Jamaica with its 12 medals — four of them gold — would be ranked No. 2. Canada, a much richer country, would be 65th.
If you account for team size, Jamaica, with its relatively small contingent of 50 and four gold medals, would rank second again. Canada, with its 277 team members, would rank 63rd.
All of this brings to mind Mark Twain’s observation that there are lies, damned lies and statistics. Ranking systems are subjective, political and flawed, unless they suit your own interests.
Of course, sports bureaucrats have a vested interest in propping up their country’s performance.
The Own the Podium program spends $34 million annually on training for elite athletes who participate in the Summer Games. The Canadian Olympic Committee sets goals: they wanted to see Canada finish in the top 12.
The Harper government also wants to refashion Canada’s image as a nation with confidence and swagger on the international stage.
Certainly Canada’s strong performance in Vancouver fuelled a national appetite for an American-style body painting and chest thumping in the supposedly reserved and polite Canadian character. It also set up an expectation for the Summer Games.
There’s nothing wrong with expectations, but a strong performance requires more than swagger, chest-thumping and self-serving ranking systems.
If Canada wants to be taken seriously in the Summer Games, it needs to wash off the body paint and face facts: we are a small country that does not invest as heavily in our Olympic athletes compared to other countries.
If we want to be that little country that “punches above our weight,” we need to allocate more money and resources in long-term development of athletes and set realistic timetables and goals.
We might also lead the charge for an international ranking standard that factors in all medal winners but also gives the first-place winners their due.
And let’s dump the “Own the Podium” brand and replace it with something less insulting to the Olympic spirit. No athlete or country, whether it’s a Phelps, Bolt, a U.S.A. or a China, owns the Olympic podium.
Gail Lethbridge is a freelance writer in Halifax. On Twitter @giftedtypist
extra funding for honest
Submitted by more equal than you on August 19, 2012 - 7:33am.
extra funding for honest judges and IOC officials is what we need to win more medals
Not medals won
Submitted by beejay on August 19, 2012 - 8:32am.
The important thing about the Olympic Games, is not the number of medals won. It is more about athletes having something to strive for, a goal. The ultimate goal would be a medal, but long before that happens there is the training and dedication required to meet that goal. The more young people participating in athletics the healthier our country. That should be our goal....and the medals will follow.
No More Money
Submitted by gregnb on August 19, 2012 - 8:57am.
Here's my two cents on the whole Olympics and should we spend money on the athletes. I think our athletes choke when it comes to the big stage. During their regular season, many of our athletes are either World Champions of their sport or rank very high. Then when it comes time to compete at the Olympics, a one shot deal, they choke. Look at the mountain biker from NB, she is the reigning world champion, choked. The female boxer who everyone pretty much guaranteed a gold, choked. Our rowers, top ranked all year, choked. It happens in the winter Olympics as well, remeber the female skeleton racer, choked. If our athletes were terrible during the regular season and struggling to keep up, then yes, look at more funding, but it seems we do alright until it comes time for the Olympics. Cough, cough, cough.
Obviously you know nothing.......
Submitted by beejay on August 19, 2012 - 9:14am.
Obviously you know nothing about life or sports, for if you did you would not make such uneducated comments. Did you even watch the Olympics ? Actually, I have nothing more to say, for your comments are not worth a rebuttle.
Thrill of victory......
Submitted by Tank on August 19, 2012 - 10:15am.
The thrill of victory and the agony of defeat, remember that old line on the Wide World of Sports show from the 70s? Some of you do, others are saying, "there was a 1970s?!" We worry too much about what other countries think of us, so screw 'em. Any Canadian who does not recognize we have a pretty sweet thing going on here needs an unsuspecting, roundhouse smack in the guts with a frozen Codfish. No Olympic medal can ever top the pride this Cannuck feels all the time for his country.